McCae Hillstead
Utah State Aggies
51
Depth

McCae Hillstead

QBOffenseDepthTRANSFER · BYU
2nd String / Backup

Is McCae Hillstead starting?

McCae Hillstead is listed 2nd string at QB for Utah State Aggies.

McCae Hillstead is listed QB #2 for Utah State at 51 OVR.

See full Utah State Aggies depth chart ›

Depth at QB · Utah State Aggies

Top quarterbacks in the Pac-12

The Story

Making His Case

A 3-star recruit out of Skyridge, ranked #1,636 nationally coming out of high school. In 2023: 1,062 passing yards, 11 TD, 8 INT. That's 1% of the team's production at his spot — good for a 51 overall (Depth tier).

Recruit3★ · #1,636 NatlTeam Share1%
Lehi, UT
Jersey
#2
Class
RS JR/TR
Height
5'10"
Weight
190 lbs
Transfer
BYU

2023 Stats

SeasonPass YdsTDINT
20231062118

Regular-season totals from public sources. Derived splits (completion %, yards per carry, catch rate) aren't available in our current dataset.

Recruiting Profile

Stars
★★★☆☆3-star
Composite
0.8433
National Rank
#1636
High School
Skyridge
Hometown
Lehi, UT

Why this rating?

On a 68-rated offense; 12th-percentile production at transfer origin (×0.97 for competition level) put them -11 vs unit starters → 51.

Team offense (SP+)
68
Rating basis
On-field stats
Production (prior school)
Outperforms 12% of peers
Recruiting pedigree
Top 50% recruit
Strength of schedule
Faces easier competition — rating adjusted down (×0.97)
Depth-chart adjustment
-11 for role; −6 depth penalty

2026 projection — based on SP+ (a respected team-efficiency metric; 2026 not published yet, using 2025), 2025 production, recruiting, and the 2026 transfer portal; capped to depth-chart order.

2026 Game Log

Oct 3LBOISYDS 47
CMP-ATT
2-7
YDS
47
TD
0
INT
1
QBR
56.4
CAR
6
YDS
10
AVG
1.7
TD
0

Final L 37-18

Sep 5LIDSTYDS 178
CMP-ATT
15-30
YDS
178
TD
2
INT
3
QBR
101.8
CAR
9
YDS
43
AVG
4.8
TD
0

Final L 29-17

McCae Hillstead's 2026 game-by-game stat log.

The People's Ratings

Is our 51 OVR fair?
51
Depth
Vote to see what thousands of fans think

Team Role

QB: 33 pass yds · 0 TD · 0 INT
Usage / Involvement100%
Coach Utah StateTake them from week one to the natty. You call every play.
DAILY PICKSMake your picks.Today's games. No account needed.

Overall ratings blend team strength (SP+), on-field production, and recruiting. Higher = more impactful.